• Havoc
  • Caius
  • redboot
  • Rules
  • Chain of Command
  • Members
  • Supported Ladders & Games
  • Downloads

Power Hour - Combat Mission: Black Sea

Power Hour Image
Combat Mission x2 - Modern Ladder

Power Hour

By Rinaldi
US 1 - 0 - 3 Russia
Rating: 5.9 (5)
Games Played: 4
SM: 7
Turns: 45
Type: Custom
First Side: US
Second Side: Russia
TF Warhorse conducts a deliberate attack to penetrate the enemy MLR. Blu v. AI, H2H only. Best played as Head to Head.
Player Voting Stats
Member Balance Enjoyment
Shorker's ProfileShorker Totally Pro US 1
Tumatauenga's ProfileTumatauenga Well Balanced 5
Tumatauenga's ProfileTumatauenga Moderately Pro Russia 5
Widukind's ProfileWidukind Well Balanced 7
A Canadian Cat's ProfileA Canadian Cat Moderately Pro US 7
Gaming Records
1st Side Player 2nd Side Player Result Score
US A Canadian Cat's Profile A Canadian Cat vs. Slingload Slingload's Profile Russia US Total Victory 77 7
US Tumatauenga's Profile Tumatauenga vs. Widukind Widukind's Profile Russia US Tactical Defeat 21 63
Russia Tumatauenga's Profile Tumatauenga vs. Widukind Widukind's Profile US Russia Tactical Victory 63 21
Russia Shorker's Profile Shorker vs. wellsonian wellsonian's Profile US Russia Minor Victory 56 28
Shorker
Captain
Shorker Wed Mar 28, 2018 10:06 am
I played this scenario on the Russian side and it was no fun to play.

1.) At the biginning your setup zone is totally limited to some fixed positions in trenches and strangely shaped earthen pits for tanks, (which have proven to be very impractical) and can hardly be changed.

2.) The Americans are attacking with helicopters but on the Russian side you have only FIVE anti-air SAM rockets, which is absolutely not enough. The Russians are exposed to the helicopters like sitting ducks with no ability to fend off the air raid.

3.) The forces are extremely unbalanced. The American side is clearly in the advantage because it has eight (!) Abrams M1 super tanks, which ward off everything in advance and always track down the enemy immediately and everywhere. The Russians, on the other hand, only have five T-90s and a pile of scrap metal.

This scenario is fun to play on the U.S. side vs. the AI in single player but in multiplayer mode I strongly dissuade, because it is designed much too rigid.
REAL OPPONENTS SEE THE BATTLE OUT TO THE END, WINNING OR LOSING
Rinaldi
Recruit
Rinaldi Frid May 04, 2018 3:00 pm
Hi Shorker, sorry you didn't enjoy the map - thank you for taking the time to play it, however.
Tumatauenga
Staff Sergeant
Tumatauenga Sun Jun 24, 2018 8:42 pm
Scoring system needs to align better with briefing. No points are awarded for exiting the map but rather for avoiding casualties, killing Russians and conserving ammo. I think it would be challenging to achieve a US victory even with superiority of equipment
Tumatauenga
Staff Sergeant
Tumatauenga Sun Jun 24, 2018 8:49 pm
I played this as a mirror game with Widukind. We disagreed on balancing. He felt it was balanced I felt it moderately pro Russian. On the face of it there is a huge weapon superiority for the US in both our games the US forces almost wiped the board of Russian defenders but the result was still a Russian tactical victory. There is no doubt that the scenario would benefit from the defender having more flexibility in positioning their forces including trenches and mine fields. I personally think the scoring needs to be re-thought, though Widukind would disagree (and I may be influenced by bad luck on my part - I lost seven(!) M-1's to bogging when I played the offensive.)
Widukind
Corporal
Widukind Mon Jun 25, 2018 6:13 am
For Both player an challenge
What's to say? A very little little let us do. And all is done. Then let the trumpets sound The tucket sonance and the note to mount;For our approach shall so much dare the field That England shall couch down in fear and yield.(Shakespeare,Henry the fith)
Rinaldi
Recruit
Rinaldi Tue Jun 26, 2018 4:05 am
Thanks and glad you enjoyed you two; Tumatauenga I agree with your frustration re: points for exiting. That would be ideal; sadly you cannot give points for exiting. "Exit" objectives are tied intrinsically to "destroy" objectives.
A Canadian Cat
Captain
A Canadian Cat Frid Aug 31, 2018 10:39 am
It was fun but pretty hard for the Russian side.
Author of: Whose Turn Is It? - http://www.lesliesoftware.com/products/WhoseTurnIsIt / CMFI Sicily Pathfinders(not playable H2H) / CMBS Opportunity Knocks (scenarios, maps and mods here)